Top Bayfield Lodging for Memorable Stays

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Valery Van der Kruk

Updated: 03 March 2024 · 2 min

Nestled along the shores of Lake Superior, Bayfield is a hidden gem for travelers seeking both beauty and tranquility. This picturesque town, known as the gateway to the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore, offers a unique blend of natural beauty, history, and adventure. For those planning a visit, choosing the right accommodation is key, and Bayfield WI hotels provide a variety of options to meet the needs and preferences of every traveler.

From charming bed and breakfasts to luxurious waterfront hotels, Bayfield's accommodation scene is as diverse as the landscapes that surround it. Each hotel in Bayfield WI presents its own unique flavor, integrating seamlessly with the town's quaint charm and the natural beauty of the region. For travelers, this means the promise of a stay that's not just comfortable but also deeply immersive, offering insights into local culture and the serene lifestyle that defines Bayfield.

Selecting the perfect Bayfield WI hotel is more than just about finding a place to rest your head; it's about enhancing your overall travel experience. Whether you're here to explore the Apostle Islands, engage in outdoor activities like kayaking and hiking, or simply to relax and take in the stunning lakeside views, the right accommodation can serve as your home base for adventure and relaxation alike. With recommendations and insights into the best Bayfield WI hotels, this guide aims to help travelers make informed decisions, ensuring a memorable stay in this enchanting corner of the United States.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 4

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Seagull Bay Motel
2. Pinehurst Inn Bed & Breakfast
3. Harbor Hill House Villa
4. Old Rittenhouse Inn

Bayfield WI Hotels: Charming Bed & Breakfasts

Check Availability

Bayfield
Mar 10, 2026 - Mar 11, 2026

Seagull Bay Motel

7.8

Good

(55 Reviews)

+ 141 photos
Seagull Bay Motel invites guests to enjoy stunning views of Lake Superior from the comfort of their rooms. This family-owned motel, a gem among Bayfield WI hotels, balances simplicity with the utmost care to ensure a pleasant stay. Each room is designed to maximize the breathtaking vistas, with easy access to Bayfield's marina, beaches, and downtown area. The motel's peaceful setting, coupled with its proximity to local attractions, makes it an ideal base for exploring the natural and cultural highlights of the region. Seagull Bay Motel's commitment to hospitality and value has made it a favorite for visitors seeking a serene waterfront escape.
Address: 325 South 7Th Street
Rating: Good 7.8 (55 Reviews)
Rooms: 31
Price: From 247$

Bayfield WI Hotels: Waterfront Escapes

Embrace the tranquility and unmatched views of Lake Superior with a selection of Bayfield's finest waterfront hotels. These hotels not only offer prime locations with direct access to the water's edge but also ensure every aspect of your stay reflects the natural beauty and serene atmosphere of Bayfield. Ideal for adventurers and romantics alike, these waterfront escapes provide the perfect backdrop for your Bayfield getaway, blending comfort, scenic vistas, and direct access to outdoor activities.

Pinehurst Inn Bed & Breakfast

9.2

Good

(19 Reviews)

+ 25 photos
At the Pinehurst Inn Bed & Breakfast, sustainability meets comfort in a beautifully restored setting. This eco-friendly inn, nestled among towering pines, offers guests a peaceful retreat with its modern amenities and environmentally conscious practices. Each room is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort while reflecting the natural beauty that surrounds the property. Guests can enjoy locally sourced breakfasts, relax in the outdoor sauna, or explore the nearby trails and waterways. Pinehurst Inn is a testament to Bayfield WI hotels' ability to blend luxury with sustainability, making it a perfect haven for eco-conscious travelers who seek harmony with nature.
Address: 83645 State Highway 13
Rating: Good 9.2 (19 Reviews)
Rooms: 8
Price: From 320$

Harbor Hill House Villa

+ 35 photos
Harbor Hill House offers an intimate bed & breakfast experience with breathtaking views of Lake Superior and the Apostle Islands. As a standout among Bayfield WI hotels, this property prides itself on its inviting rooms, each meticulously decorated to enhance the home's historic charm while offering modern conveniences. The wraparound porch is a guest favorite, providing a tranquil spot to enjoy morning coffee or evening sunsets. The Harbor Hill House's gourmet breakfast is a culinary journey, highlighting local ingredients and flavors. This bed & breakfast encapsulates the warmth and hospitality that Bayfield is known for, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a personalized and memorable stay.
Address: 141 N. Front Street
Price: From 875$

Old Rittenhouse Inn

9.5

Good

(2 Reviews)

+ 98 photos
The Old Rittenhouse Inn is not just a place to stay; it's a step back in time to an era of elegant charm and refined hospitality. This historic mansion, recognized as one of the premier Bayfield WI hotels, offers guests a luxurious retreat with its beautifully appointed rooms, some featuring whirlpool baths and fireplaces. The Inn is renowned for its gourmet breakfasts and fine dining, set against the backdrop of Lake Superior's stunning views. The property's lush gardens and welcoming common areas provide the perfect setting for relaxation. The Old Rittenhouse Inn stands out for its attention to detail and commitment to providing guests with a memorable stay that encapsulates the essence of Bayfield's historic grandeur.
Address: 301 Rittenhouse Avenue
Rating: Good 9.5 (2 Reviews)
Rooms: 20
Price: From 185$