Top Hotels in Buffalo Wyoming to Stay

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Valery Van der Kruk

Updated: 25 February 2024 · 6 min

Nestled against the majestic backdrop of the Bighorn Mountains, Buffalo offers a unique blend of Western history, stunning landscapes, and small-town charm that attracts visitors year-round. With its rich history, including tales of the Old West and ties to the legendary Bozeman Trail, Buffalo serves not only as a gateway to outdoor adventures but also as a cozy retreat into America's past. For those looking to immerse themselves in this enchanting environment, finding the perfect hotel in Buffalo can significantly enhance your experience, blending comfort with the essence of the wild West.

The selection of hotels in Buffalo caters to a wide range of preferences and budgets, ensuring that every traveler finds their ideal lodging. From historic hotels that whisper tales of bygone eras to modern accommodations that provide all the contemporary comforts you could ask for, Buffalo's hospitality scene is as diverse as its landscape. Each hotel promises not only a place to rest but also an opportunity to experience the local culture and warmth, making your stay an integral part of your journey.

Choosing the right hotel in Buffalo is crucial for adventurers eager to explore the Bighorn National Forest, history buffs fascinated by the storied past of the American West, and families looking for a peaceful getaway. The best hotels offer not just a room, but a doorway to the heart of Buffalo, with recommendations on local attractions, dining, and insights into hidden gems. This guide aims to help you navigate through the myriad of options, ensuring your accommodation in Buffalo not only meets but exceeds your expectations, making your trip an unforgettable adventure.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 10

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Rodeway Inn
2. Mountain Views, 2 Bedrooms 1 Bath Home Pets Ok
3. Creekside Downtown Vacation Suites, Only Adults 25 Or Older
4. Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo
5. Historic Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites Downtown
6. Super 8 By Wyndham Buffalo Hotel
7. Mansion House Motel
8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Buffalo, An Ihg Hotel
9. Big Horn Motel
10. Quality Inn

Historic Charm Hotels in Buffalo, WY

Check Availability

Buffalo
Dec 11, 2025 - Dec 12, 2025

Rodeway Inn

+ 93 photos
The Rodeway Inn provides guests with an affordable way to enjoy Buffalo and the surrounding areas. Known for its friendly service and comfortable accommodations, this hotel offers great value for travelers. Amenities like free breakfast and Wi-Fi contribute to an economical stay without compromising on essential comforts. The Rodeway Inn's location makes it easy for guests to explore Buffalo, from historical sites to outdoor adventures, ensuring a memorable trip that won't overextend your budget.
Address: 610 E Hart Street
Rooms: 27
Price: From 59$

Mountain Views, 2 Bedrooms 1 Bath Home Pets Ok

+ 6 photos
For adventure seekers traveling with pets, finding the right accommodation can be challenging. The Mountain Views home offers not just pet-friendly accommodations but also an idyllic setting with stunning mountain vistas. This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home provides ample space for a family or group of friends seeking adventure in the Buffalo area. Its location serves as a fantastic launching point for outdoor activities, with the comfort of returning to a home away from home. For those who dream of waking up to breathtaking views and ending days of exploration in a cozy, private setting, this property is an unparalleled choice.
Address: 331 Hemlock Street

Family-Friendly Hotels in Buffalo, WY

When traveling with the family, finding the right accommodation can make all the difference in your trip. The family-friendly hotels in Buffalo are designed to cater to the needs of guests of all ages, offering amenities and services that ensure a comfortable and enjoyable stay for everyone. From spacious rooms to complimentary breakfast options and pools for the kids to splash in, these hotels know what it takes to host a happy, content family. Their strategic locations also mean that family attractions are never too far away, making them ideal bases from which to explore all that Buffalo has to offer families on vacation.

Creekside Downtown Vacation Suites, Only Adults 25 Or Older

9.2

Good

(46 Reviews)

+ 24 photos
For those seeking a more intimate and historically immersive experience, the Creekside Downtown Vacation Suites offers an exclusive retreat. These adult-only suites cater to guests looking for tranquility and a touch of historical charm in the very heart of Buffalo. With attention to preserving the historical integrity of the property, each suite combines antique elegance with modern amenities, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay. The creekside location provides a serene backdrop, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring Buffalo's rich history. It's an ideal choice for travelers seeking a blend of history, comfort, and exclusivity.
Address: 68 North Side Creek
Rating: Good 9.2 (46 Reviews)
Price: From 147$

Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo

9.1

Good

(209 Reviews)

+ 97 photos
The Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo stands out as an ideal family-friendly hotel, offering a range of amenities designed to cater to guests of all ages. Families can enjoy spacious rooms with comfortable bedding, ensuring a good night's sleep for everyone. The hotel's complimentary breakfast is a hit with kids and adults alike, offering a variety of healthy and indulgent options. The indoor pool is a family favorite, providing entertainment regardless of the weather. Situated near key attractions, the Hampton Inn & Suites makes exploring Buffalo easy and convenient for families looking for fun and adventure.
Address: 85 Us Highway 16 East
Rating: Good 9.1 (209 Reviews)
Rooms: 75
Price: From 97$

Adventure Seekers’ Accommodations in Buffalo, WY

Buffalo is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts and adventure seekers, offering easy access to the breathtaking landscapes of the Bighorn Mountains and a plethora of outdoor activities. The hotels in this section are chosen for their ability to cater to those who love adventure, providing amenities like gear storage, proximity to outdoor attractions, and knowledgeable staff ready to help you plan your perfect adventure. Whether you're in town to hike, fish, hunt, or simply to breathe in the fresh mountain air, these hotels will serve as the perfect base camp for your adventures.

Historic Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites Downtown

8.5

Good

(24 Reviews)

+ 73 photos
Step into the Historic Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites Downtown and find yourself enveloped in the elegance of the late 19th century. This landmark hotel boasts original architectural details and antique furnishings, offering guests a genuinely historic experience. Each suite is designed with an eye for authenticity, ensuring that guests feel the historical significance of their surroundings without sacrificing comfort. Located in the vibrant downtown area, the hotel provides easy access to Buffalo's cultural and historical attractions. The Historic Capitol Hotel is more than a place to stay; it is a journey into the grandeur of the past, making it a perfect retreat for history buffs and romantic getaways.
Address: 70 South Main Street
Rating: Good 8.5 (24 Reviews)
Price: From 168$

Super 8 By Wyndham Buffalo Hotel

5.5

Good

(91 Reviews)

+ 47 photos
The Super 8 By Wyndham Buffalo stands as a beacon of value and comfort in the very heart of Wyoming. Offering guests clean, comfortable rooms at competitive rates, this hotel ensures that saving money doesn't mean sacrificing comfort. Guests can enjoy complimentary breakfast, Wi-Fi, and parking, adding value to an already affordable stay. Its convenient location allows easy access to Buffalo's main attractions, making the Super 8 By Wyndham an excellent choice for budget-savvy travelers.
Address: 655 E. Hart St
Rating: Good 5.5 (91 Reviews)
Rooms: 48
Price: From 66$

Budget-Friendly Hotels in Buffalo, WY

Traveling on a budget doesn't mean you have to compromise on quality or convenience. The budget-friendly hotels in Buffalo offer visitors comfortable accommodations, friendly service, and easy access to Buffalo's attractions without breaking the bank. These hotels are selected for budget-conscious travelers who want to maximize their travel experiences while minimizing expenses. From complimentary amenities to exceptional value, these accommodations ensure that your stay in Buffalo is both affordable and enjoyable.

Mansion House Motel

8.0

Good

(86 Reviews)

+ 62 photos
The Mansion House Motel offers guests a unique opportunity to experience Buffalo's historic allure. Nestled in the lively heart of the city, this motel has been a beacon of hospitality, welcoming travelers with its vintage charm and personalized service. Each room in the Mansion House Motel is decorated to reflect the rich history of Buffalo, providing a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere that transports guests back in time. Its central location makes it an ideal base for exploring local historical sites, ensuring a memorable and immersive stay. The motel prides itself on balancing historical authenticity with modern conveniences, promising a stay that's both comfortable and culturally enriching.
Address: 313 North Main Street
Rating: Good 8.0 (86 Reviews)
Rooms: 10
Price: From 87$

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Buffalo, An Ihg Hotel

8.0

Good

(131 Reviews)

+ 62 photos
Families will find a welcoming abode at the Holiday Inn Express & Suites Buffalo, an IHG Hotel. Known for its dependable quality and service, this hotel offers suites that accommodate larger families comfortably, with plenty of space for everyone. The complimentary breakfast buffet is a morning highlight, featuring options that will satisfy even the pickiest eaters. The outdoor pool is perfect for cooling off on warm days, offering fun for kids and relaxation for adults. Located within easy reach of Buffalo's family-friendly attractions, the Holiday Inn Express & Suites is an excellent choice for families seeking convenience and comfort.
Address: 106 East Highway 16
Rating: Good 8.0 (131 Reviews)
Rooms: 69
Price: From 100$

Big Horn Motel

8.5

Good

(262 Reviews)

+ 76 photos
Perfectly situated for those seeking adventure in Buffalo, the Big Horn Motel offers a cozy retreat near the Bighorn Mountains. Its location is ideal for visitors planning to hike, fish, or partake in winter sports, providing an affordable yet comfortable place to rest. The motel prides itself on its welcoming atmosphere and personalized service, ensuring that adventurers have a hassle-free base to return to. The Big Horn Motel stands as a testament to Wyoming's spirit of adventure, making it a perfect fit for those looking to explore the wild beauty of the area.
Address: 209 North Main Street
Rating: Good 8.5 (262 Reviews)
Rooms: 20
Price: From 70$

Quality Inn

7.3

Good

(189 Reviews)

+ 119 photos
The Quality Inn provides a cozy, budget-friendly option for families visiting Buffalo comfortable, spacious rooms and a complimentary breakfast that takes the hassle out of morning meals, families can start their day off right. The outdoor swimming pool is a welcome feature during the summer months, offering a refreshing break from exploring. The hotel's location makes it easy for families to access local parks and attractions, ensuring that fun is never far away. The Quality Inn stands as a testament to the idea that traveling with family doesn't have to break the bank to be enjoyable and comfortable.
Address: 75 North Bypass Road
Rating: Good 7.3 (189 Reviews)
Rooms: 60
Price: From 66$

Alamo Inn

7.2

Good

(268 Reviews)

+ 35 photos
Offering comfort and convenience at a great price, the Alamo Inn is an ideal choice for travelers keeping an eye on their budgets. With clean, well-appointed rooms and a friendly atmosphere, guests can enjoy a stress-free stay. The Inn's proximity to local dining and attractions, along with competitive rates, makes it a standout option for those wanting to experience Buffalo without spending a fortune. The Alamo Inn proves that budget accommodations can still provide a quality, enjoyable experience.
Address: 333 East Hart St
Rating: Good 7.2 (268 Reviews)
Rooms: 42
Price: From 70$